2009
Photoshop

Space Shuttle Patch

NASA conducted a contest in 2009-2010 to design a Space Shuttle Program Commemorative Patch. The contest invited all current and former employees of NASA and its contractors to submit ideas for a patch to commemorate the retirement of the space shuttle. The winning patch will be used to celebrate the accomplishments of the Space Shuttle Program when it retires in 2010.

Entries were judged by a team of managers from the Space Shuttle Program. The winning patch design will be flown on an upcoming mission, and the winner will be presented with their flown artwork as an award.

While my design, shown above, did not place among the top three, it was one of the top 15 finalists chosen out of a total of 85 entries received. Thanks to all who voted for my design.

A "People's Choice Award" vote was also conducted for NASA employees in January 2010. My design placed fifth among the top 15 finalists in the NASA employees' voting. I received 506 votes (6.7%) out of a total of 7606.

All 85 entries, the top 15 finalists, and the NASA managers' top three winners can be seen on NASA's Space Shuttle web site.

collectSPACE.com conducted its own unofficial "Fans' Choice" poll at the same time NASA was having its "People's Choice Award" vote. My design placed sixth among the top 15 finalists in the collectSPACE poll, receiving 275 votes (8.6%) out of a total of 3206.

The final results of their poll can be seen on the collectSPACE Fan's Choice Poll web page.


Design Concepts

I created four different designs for the contest, plus several variations of each one. From those, I chose as my entry the one (shown above) that I believed best captured the spirit of what NASA was looking for to commemorate the many great accomplishments of the Space Shuttle program.

Deciding how best to capture the NASA's achievements with the Space Shuttle on a single patch proved to be a challenge. Most traditional mission patches include images that represent the goals and activities for the particular flight. When researching all of the past flights, I was amazed at how many notable milestones have been marked during the span of the Shuttle program. It quickly became clear that I would only be able to represent a few of these things.

The first reusable spacecraft.
First operational spacecraft to launch as a rocket and land as a glider.
First use of a drag chute during a Shuttle landing.
The science done on Spacelab and Spacelab-J.
First untethered space walks using the Manned Maneuvering Unit (MMU).
Launching, servicing, and astronomy of the Hubble Space Telescope.
Rendezvous and docking with the Russian MIR space station.
Construction, servicing, and populating of the International Space Station.
International crews and agencies (Russia, Japan, Italy, Germany, France, more …).
First U.S. woman in space (Sally Ride).
First African-American in space (Guy Bluford).
First African-American woman in space (Mae Jemison).
First U.S. female pilot and commander (Eileen Collins).
First married couple to fly on the same space mission.
First deployment and retrieval of an astronomy satellite.
First EVA involving three astronauts.
First Shuttle mission to feature four EVAs.
First Shuttle mission requiring three rendezvous with an orbiting spacecraft.
Attached a live rocket motor to an orbiting satellite.
Successful hand capture by Pierre Thuot, Richard Hieb, and Thomas Akers.
... and more ...

NASA requested that artists include a description of their design, along with the artwork. Presented here are my four designs together with descriptions and some samples of the variations.


2009
Photoshop

Concept 1

The design above celebrates the Space Shuttle’s thirty years of orbital operations (1981 – 2010) and the many great accomplishments of the Space Shuttle program. It is modeled after the traditional mission crew patches that have been used on space flights since the 1960's.

The Space Shuttle Orbiter is shown prominently over the Earth. Three other spacecraft join the Space Shuttle in this design, symbolizing just a few of the many achievements made possible by the Shuttle program.

To the left of the Shuttle is the International Space Station (ISS), which was launched, assembled, and populated largely by Space Shuttle missions (together with Russian modules and vehicles).

Shown above the ISS is an astronaut floating free in space using a Manned Maneuvering Unit (MMU). The MMU was first demonstrated in space on a Shuttle flight.

To the right of the orbiter is the Hubble Space Telescope. The Hubble was launched into space, placed in orbit, and serviced several times using the Space Shuttle. Stars and a galaxy represent the expanding knowledge of the universe the Hubble has given us.

The Moon and Mars are illustrated to represent the future direction of human space exploration, and the many science achievements the Space Shuttle program has contributed toward those goals.

Six small stars represent the six orbiters in the Shuttle fleet. The names of the six vehicles of the fleet (including Enterprise) surround the design.

The two seven pointed stars, placed near the names of Columbia and Challenger pay tribute to the loss of those orbiters and the seven member astronaut crews of each of those missions.


2009
Photoshop

Concept 2

The simple graphic design above emphasizes the three decades the U.S. space program used shuttles to send humans and equipment into orbit.

The Space Shuttle Orbiter is shown in glowing silhouette orbiting a brilliant blue crescent Earth. The Earth’s near circle creates part of the number 30, the number of years the Shuttles will have flown in space since the first flight in 1981 to the final flight projected to be in 2010.

The names of the six vehicles of the fleet (including Enterprise) surround the design.


2009
Photoshop
2009
Photoshop

Concept 3

The design above celebrates the Space Shuttle’s thirty years of orbital operations (1981 – 2010).

The Space Shuttle Orbiter is shown in glowing silhouette. The booster rockets and external tank are rendered in white and gray, recalling the design of the original Space Shuttle program patch as well as the painted white external tank used during the first launches.

The names of the six vehicles of the fleet (including Enterprise) surround the design.

A variation of the basic design is shown on the right. Three other spacecraft join the Space Shuttle in this design, symbolizing just a few of the many achievements made possible by the Shuttle program.

Superimposed over the orbiter is an astronaut floating free in space using a Manned Maneuvering Unit (MMU). The MMU was first demonstrated in space on a Shuttle flight.

Over the Shuttle’s payload bay is a silhouette of the Hubble Space Telescope. The Hubble was launched into space, placed in orbit, and serviced several times using the Space Shuttle.

Shown behind the Shuttle stack is the International Space Station (ISS), which was launched, assembled, and populated largely by Space Shuttle missions (together with Russian modules and vehicles).


2009
Photoshop
2009
Photoshop

Concept 4

The simple triangular design above celebrates the Space Shuttle’s thirty years of orbital operations.

The Space Shuttle Orbiter is shown in glowing silhouette. Three blue shock diamonds represent the three decades the Space Shuttle has been in service.

The triangular shape recalls the design of the original Space Shuttle program patch.

The names of the six vehicles of the fleet (including Enterprise) fan out below the Orbiter.


In the news ...

The local newspaper in Redmond, Washington ran a story about me.

Redmond Reporter

Redmond's 'Rocketman' among finalists in NASA contest for Space Shuttle patch


The story of NASA's patch contest has appeared in the following places:

NASA.gov

Space Shuttle Program Announces Commemorative Patch Contest Winner

collectSPACE.com

NASA launches in-house patch contest to mark shuttle era's end

Astronauts, space workers submit designs for NASA's end-of-shuttle patch contest

Designing an uplifting end to NASA's space shuttle program

NASA selects 15 finalists for end-of-shuttle commemorative patch contest

NASA employees, public pick favorites for end-of-shuttle program patch

NASA announces winning patch design in end-of-shuttle contest

Space.com

NASA Selects Finalists for End-of-Shuttle Patch Contest

Wired.com

Wired Science: NASA’s Contest to Design the Last Shuttle Patch

Wired Science: Winner (and Losers) of NASA’s Final Shuttle Patch Contest

MSNBC

CosmicLog: The last patch ... and much more

FloridayToday.com

Patch designs snag the fabric of shuttle

SliceofSciFi.com

NASA Holds Contest For Final Space Shuttle Patch

NPR.org

NASA Holds Contest For Final Space Shuttle Patch

gizmodo.com

Here's the Final Space Shuttle Mission Patch


One of the entrants posted her artistic critique of the top 15 designs on her blog. She has training in graphic design. She also happens to be a Flight Controller at the Johnson Space Center.

Sarah at saroy.net

Commemorating the Shuttle Program


Susan Freeman, an International Space Station engineer at the Johnson Space Center and a graphic designer, offered her critique of almost 40 designs. She also posted meticulously crafted charts tracking the progress of the voting for both the collectSPACE poll and the internal NASA contest.

Rocket Shot by RocketGirl (Susan Freeman)

Designing an Uplifting End to the Shuttle Program

RocketGirl's voting updates:
January 12 | January 15 | January 25 | February 2

Shuttle Commemorative Patch Winner


Other blog sites:

Damaris Sarria

Space Shuttle Program Commemorative Patch



Copyright © 2000-2010. Dave Ginsberg. All rights reserved.